Customer Reviews for Piano Sonatas - Volume 2
Location: from United Kingdom
May 2, 2010
Good Edition - For Sonatas 7 & 9!
The reason that I bought this book was to study and play sonatas 6 & 8. Unfortunately, I compared the two sonatas to other editions and found some errors. For example, the 3rd movmt in the 6th sonata is missing several slurs and in Sonata No.8, so many articulations are missing! Precipitato, meno mosso etc. I was extremely disappointed by this edition. However, I No.7 & No.9 are reliable, as they are bare soviet reprints, which Sikorski also does separately, but for no.6 and 8 I definitely recommend a single Sikorski Edition.
21 of 36 people found this review helpful.